logo

52 pages 1 hour read

Mark Bowden

Black Hawk Down: A Story of Modern War

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 1999

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 2: “Black Hawk Down”

Part 2, Chapter 1 Summary

Mohamad Hassan Farah hears the helicopters approaching. He is still healing from wounds sustained in an American helicopter attack three months prior. Farah had originally welcomed the UN intervention, but has since come to hate the UN Secretary Boutros Boutros-Ghali, an enemy of General Aidid. Farah believes the US troops were duped into helping Boutros-Ghali, who secretly wishes to restore the Darod, a rival clan of Habr Gidr.

In the previous attack, Farah had been at a Habr Gidr meeting when an American helicopter began launching missiles. Farah was left with gashes in his arms and back from shrapnel. He escaped, thinking, “this business of sending US Rangers swooping down into their city kidnapping and killing their leaders, this was too much” (74). Eventually, the attack Farah survived would come to be known as the Abdi House attack.

Attorney Bashir Haji Yusuf also heard the helicopters on the day of the raid. He is disappointed in the Americans. He received some education in America and has friends there, so he knows that the troops mean well. He believes the Americans’ intention to destroy the clan is ignorant: “Didn’t the Americans realize that for every leader they arrested there were dozens of brothers, cousins, sons, and nephews to take his place?” (75). Yusuf does not support Aidid unequivocally, but he has begun to share the “popular anger toward the American forces” (76). 

Part 2, Chapter 2 Summary

The narrative shifts back to the American troops, where Specialist John Waddell looks up from the fighting to see a Black Hawk twisting strangely in the air. Nelson saw the RPG hit the helicopter’s tail. He knows it will crash. 

Part 2, Chapter 3 Summary

Pilot Ray Dowdy felt the hit to Black Hawk Super Six One but did not think the RPG had seriously damaged it. He is a brave pilot, whose legendary exploits and hundreds of secret missions have endeared him to the men. Like the other Rangers, when the crowds grew too thick for him to identify the shooters, he began firing into the crowd. When a Black Hawk had gone down in a previous incident, Somali mobs had mutilated the corpses of the men inside, and Dowdy feels justified in shooting civilians.

 

Super Six One crashes in an alley, clipping the roof of a house on its way down. 

Part 2, Chapter 4 Summary

Over the radio, the Rangers shout about the Black Hawk crashing. Bowden notes that “There was no pretense now of that deadpan military cool” (80). 

Part 2, Chapter 5 Summary

Super Six One hit the house of Abdiaziz Ali Aden, one teenager in a house of 11 children. Prior to the Super Six One’s descent, Aden hears the fighting and exits to see dead people in the streets. He watches the militiaman shoot the RPG that downs the helicopter. After it crashes, he runs into the house to find his family trapped under a sheet of their tin roof, but they are unharmed and he frees them. They all go to a friend’s house, worried that the helicopter might explode. On the way, Aden sees a Ranger kill both a man and a woman. He “curled himself up tight and wished he was someplace else” (83).

Part 2, Chapter 6 Summary

General Garrison watches the crash on the screen at the compound. He knows that regaining the initiative will result in more casualties. Because he can see men crawling out of the helicopter, he knows that they have to mount a new offensive to help them. A mission that he had designed for speed is now stuck. Thousands of Somalis are converging on the plumes of smoke from the crash, and Garrison watches the ring of bodies closing in on the American troops. He sends word to the 10th Mountain Division troops in the city to mobilize. This decision will pit 150 Americans against thousands of Somalis. 

Part 2, Chapter 7 Summary

Nelson runs in the direction of the crash, desperate to help. Lieutenant DiTomasso follows him with eight Rangers, after ordering half of Chalk Four to stay behind and draw fire. Three blocks away, Nelson sees that a “Little Bird,” or smaller helicopter, has landed in an alley so tight that its blades are almost touching the walls.

Part 2, Chapter 8 Summary

Chief Warrant Officers Karl Maier and Keith Jones are piloting Black Hawk Star Four One. They land, and Somalis immediately attacked. The Americans meet with Nelson and DiTomasso, and together they drag a wounded man named Busch away from the downed helicopter. Jones gets on the radio and says, “Four One is coming out” (87).

Part 2, Chapter 9 Summary

Chief Warrant Officer Mike Durant knows that the two pilots from Super Six One, nicknamed Elvis and Bull, are probably dead. He is surprised that the RPG managed to hit the Black Hawk and take it down, given the awkward nature of shooting an RPG into the sky, and the near indestructibility of the Black Hawks. He regards its loss as “a one-in-a-million event” (88).

Durant is part of an elite group of pilots known as the Night Stalkers, and he specializes in high-risk missions and methodical training. He continues circling and watching the conflict, waiting for orders, because “breaking discipline meant becoming a greater hazard than the enemy” (90).

Part 2, Chapter 10 Summary

Admiral Jonathan Howe learns of the raid and the downed helicopter. After serving as the deputy national security adviser for President Bush, he is in Mogadishu acting as Boutros-Ghali’s “top man” (91). Howe shares much of the responsibility for bringing the Rangers to Mogadishu after becoming obsessed with Aidid. Howe believes that removing Aidid from command will solve most of Somalia’s problems. When he had arrived in Mogadishu, he had seen it as a “country not just at ground zero, but below zero” (92). After months of failing to capture Aidid, Howe persuaded the Clinton administration to send in Delta troops and Rangers. As he observes the raid, he hopes “there would be more of an appetite in Washington to get rid of this upstart warlord once and for all” (97).

Part 2, Chapter 11 Summary

Abdi Karim Mohamud is a Somali secretary at the US embassy compound. He is also a spy for Habr Gidr, his clan. After the Abdi House attack, his idealism about the UN mission crumbled, and he stayed at the embassy to gain information. On the day of the raid, he goes home to find his father, brothers, and sisters hiding in their courtyard. Abdi joins the crowds heading toward the market, the site of the heaviest fighting. He’s frightened by the gunfire and hides in a friend’s house.

Part 2, Chapter 12 Summary

Staff Sergeant Dan Schilling was in the convoy’s lead Humvee when the fighting began. When Super Six One goes down, his commanders order him to the crash site with six Humvees and two flatbed trucks. It is only five blocks away, but “[t]hey were driving into the bloodiest phase of the battle” (101).

Part 2, Chapter 13 Summary

Durant is to fly Super Six Four where Super Six One should have been. He circles low over the city, and it is hard to make sense of the fighting below or see who the enemies are. On his fifth circle, “his chopper hit something hard” (103).

Part 2, Chapter 14 Summary

Sergeants Jeff McLaughlin and Casey Joyce rejoin Chalk Four after transporting Blackburn to the medic. McLaughlin is firing at a Somali fighter when the convoy passes behind him, and he gets into a vehicle driven by Private Tory Carlson. They reach the five remaining able-bodied men of Chalk Four a hundred yards away. Eversmann puts his wounded men into the vehicles, and the convoy head toward the crash site. The men in the back of the convoy still don’t know that the chopper went down and think they are driving back to base. A woman holding a baby runs out of an alley aiming a pistol, and Spalding shoots her.

Part 2, Chapter 15 Summary

Pilot Mike Goffena sees the RPG that hits Super Six Four’s tail rotor. He radios Durant to describe the damage to him. At first, Durant doesn’t feel that anything mechanical is wrong, then the tail rotor evaporates. The helicopter begins to shake and spin. Durant manages to land the Black Hawk hard, but it is a flat landing, “which meant there was a chance the men in the helicopter were still alive” (108).

Part 2, Chapter 16 Summary

Yousef Dahir Mo’alim saw the man who fired the RPG. He is part of a 26-man militia group that came running from another village when the fighting began. Mo’alim is a veteran soldier, and his men are considered bandits and “fearless fighters.” Mo’alim knows that taking down a helicopter is the best way to fight the Americans, who have one weakness: “they were not willing to die” (110). Clan members are always ready to die, and they see retreat as a sign of weakness. When the second Black Hawk goes down, Mo’alim and his men run toward the crash, hoping to kill any surviving Americans.

Part 2, Chapter 17 Summary

Pilots Harrell and Matthews watch the convoy, which must stop at every intersection because there is a new ambush waiting for them at the end of each block. The pilots try to direct the convoy down streets without roadblocks. In the convoy, McKnight learns that the second Black Hawk has crashed, and officers order him to steer the convoy to the second crash site to help.

An RPG hits the third vehicle in the convoy, knocking its passengers out onto the street, severely injuring two of them. Delta Master Sergeant Tim Martin loses the lower half of his body in the explosion, and Private Adalberto Rodriguez loses most of one thigh to shrapnel. Somalis shoot Sergeant Casey Joyce in the back, critically injuring him, and they shoot and kill Corporal Jim Cavaco.

Part 2, Chapter 18 Summary

Harrell radios McKnight and accidentally gives him the wrong directions to the crash site of Durant’s Black Hawk Super Six Four.

Part 2, Chapter 19 Summary

As the convoy moves, “Some of the men were at the breaking point” (119). Some of the Rangers have their heads down and are shaking, not looking at the fighting.

Private Carlson has been shot in the leg. He looks at the wound, and “One second he was paralyzed with fear and pain, and the next, he had stopped caring about himself” (120). He tells himself he will go down fighting, even if all he can do is help the men around him.

Private Ed Kallman is driving a Humvee in the convoy. He keeps telling himself, This is not supposed to happen” (121). He doesn’t understand why they aren’t getting more help. An RPG hits his vehicle, and he regains consciousness seconds later outside on the ground. He runs after the convoy.

At each intersection, Eversmann sees lines of Somalis firing at them. Eversmann feels that “these people must have no regard for their own lives. They just did not care” (125). 

Part 2, Chapter 20 Summary

A bullet ricochets through Spalding’s open Humvee window, hitting him in the knee. Seconds later, in the same vehicle, another bullet strikes Maddox in the helmet. He survives but is temporarily blind from the impact.

Othic is in a truck driven by Private Richard Kowalewski. A two-foot-long missile enters through a window and pierces Kowalewski’s chest without killing him. His truck crashes into the one in front of it. Several of the vehicles are low on ammunition. Nearly half of the 75 men in the convoy sustain wounds, and eight are dead. Things were not going as planned: “It was 5:40 P.M. They had been battling through the streets now for more than an hour” (131).

Part 2 Analysis

Part 2 continues the rapid-fire sequence of events the US troops are experiencing but begins to show the viewpoints of more Somali people. This allows Bowden—who interviewed many people on both sides of the conflict—to explain some of the reasons for the tension among Somalia, America, and the United Nations. Part 2 also delves into the Somali’s mistrust and anger against US troops, which helps to further explain the actions of the mob.

Farrah did not feel overly hostile toward the Americans until the Abdi House attack left him wounded. The missile strike looked careless to him, as if the Americans did not care about collateral damage. The trajectory of his growing anger is logical: He sees his countrymen attacked and killed by a foreign force that has overstayed its welcome.

Yusuf is more sympathetic toward the UN than Farrah, and he is not an unequivocal supporter of Aidid. He is excited about the prospect of the United Nation’s efforts to help Somalia, but his optimism withers in the face of the repeated American attacks and the ensuing collateral damage. He’s frustrated by the short-sighted nature of the American plan and points out that once they thwart a warlord like Aidid, his relatives will quickly replace him.

Howe’s obsession with capturing Aidid relies on the assumption that Aidid is the source of the problems in Somalia and that the tyranny will end with him. The clan culture in Somalia is unfamiliar to the Americans. Had the American leadership taken more time to understand the nature of the Somali clan and honor systems, they may not have fixated on Aidid’s removal as a panacea. They also might have become aware of more opportunities to maintain positive relations with the Somali populace. By the time the raid begins, even men like Yusuf are succumbing to what he calls “the popular anger” toward the US troops.

Mo’alim’s point of view gives us glimpses of the mob’s mentality. He sees the Rangers as courageous, foolhardy, and afraid of death. Though the Rangers willingly enter high-risk situations and armed conflicts, Mo’alim sees tactical retreats as a sign of weakness. From the Americans’ perspective, the Somalis rarely consider strategy; they charge and fire their weapons, taking unnecessary casualties by exposing themselves. Their actions demonstrate that they would rather die rather than appear weak.

Howe’s obsession with capturing Aidid is myopic. By the end of the book, the commanders realize that there is no easy answer for the situation in Somalia. Howe’s belief that eliminating Aidid will instantly fix Somalia’s gravest problems is well-intentioned but naïve, particularly considering Yusuf’s perspective on the clan system. A military mind thinks in terms of concrete solutions, because that attitude makes it easier to plan a mission, but focusing on an objective without insight can cause blind spots and distract from better solutions.

When Durant crashes, a second Black Hawk is down, and another hugely improbable event has happened in little more than an hour. Eight American soldiers are dead, and the men still have over 13 hours of fighting ahead of them.

The mob continues to grow, and it is difficult to imagine a chance of survival for the US troops.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text