46 pages • 1 hour read
Holly BlackA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Charlie prepares to confront Vince but worries that he might try to harm her. She waits for him to come home and then admits she knows his real name and his past. Vince becomes defensive and admits he’s killed before, for Lionel Salt. He hints that he has the Liber Noctem. They argue, and Vince leaves.
Charlie decides to take out her frustration by stealing from Adam and returning Adam to his girlfriend.
Charlie dresses up to sneak into Adam’s hotel and steal his book. She assesses her environment like a professional thief and manages to steal a maid’s keycard. Inside Adam’s room, she finds a pawn shop receipt for a ring that belonged to Doreen and a notebook belonging to Knight Singh. As she prepares to leave, Adam returns, talking on the phone with someone about a horse race. Charlie hides in the bathroom. She tries to will her shadow to defend her, but it stays silent. When she hears Adam say he’ll take a shower, she texts Doreen and tells her about the ring. Doreen calls Adam and convinces him to meet her. He leaves, and Charlie is able to escape. Charlie goes to the pawn shop and trades the race tip she overheard from Adam for Doreen’s ring.
Before going home, Charlie goes to the address on Edmund Carver’s driver’s license and rings the buzzer. A man answers and acts afraid of Carver’s name. Charlie goes to the trash and finds discarded junk mail belonging to one of the apartments.
Remy’s shadow remembers his relationship with Remy.
Remy taught the shadow to feel human emotions. Sometimes they went to the supermarket with their mother, and she ordered them to steal things. Then they went to Remy’s grandfather, who forced the shadow to kill. Taking lives changed it and made it stronger. The shadow experimented with moving farther away and becoming more independent.
Charlie goes to an all-night bar to meet Doreen. When Doreen arrives, she tries to defend Adam’s theft. Charlie offers Doreen her ring back in exchange for Doreen using her connections to push Posey’s tuition debt repayment back three months. Doreen is annoyed but agrees. However, she returns shortly to say that Charlie’s account was blocked and she wasn’t able to alter it. Charlie relents and returns the ring anyway, feeling sorry for herself. She drinks the night away until she’s ejected for violence.
Later, she wakes in her car feeling ashamed. When she emerges, she meets a man beside her car: Lionel Salt, who offers her a job.
Lionel Salt coerces Charlie into his car, where a young woman named Adeline is waiting. Charlie recognizes her from the photo Vince always carries around in his wallet. Salt wants Charlie to retrieve his stolen Book of Night.
They go to a spa where Charlie and Adeline freshen up and talk about Edmund, whom Adeline calls Remy. Afterward, they join Salt for lunch, where he expands on his plan to retrieve the book before he joins the Cabal. Salt explains that Edmund fed his shadow, cared for it too much, and named it Red. Eventually, Red was freed and is now loose in the world. Edmund wants the Book of Night to turn Red into a living person, but Salt is trying to get the book back before the process is complete.
When Charlie refuses to steal the book for him, Salt uses his shadow to possess her. He implies that if she doesn’t do as he asks, he’ll force her to hurt Posey. Charlie reluctantly agrees. On her way out of the restaurant, she meets the Hierophant, who tells her that he’s looking for Red.
The narrative flashes back to Remy’s childhood. Remy stood on a street at night alone, waiting for his shadow, Red, to kill someone for Lionel Salt. While Red approached a sleeping man inside a building, Remy tried to convince himself his new wealth was worth his actions. After murdering the people inside, Red returned to Remy. As Remy reminded himself that Red was only an extension of his subconscious, a place where he put his anger and fear, Red asked to be cut loose, promising to always return.
The narrative returns to the present. Charlie receives a gift from Salt: a book of fairy tales bookmarked to “The Shadow”—a story about a scholar who sent his shadow away and only reconnected with it years later. The shadow forced the scholar to be his servant, and eventually, the scholar was killed. Charlie takes it as a message that Vince is in danger from Red.
She arrives home and tells Posey that Vince is gone. They talk about Rand, whom Posey and their father thought was sexually grooming Charlie.
Hoping to find more clues, Charlie goes to Paul Ecco’s bookshop. She digs through his files and discovers a secret list of occult books and paraphernalia, from which she learns about instances of shadow magic throughout history. She also sees a book of collected records and letters about the bookshop’s business transactions. In it, she discovers that the Liber Noctem was sold to Paul Ecco by a man named Liam Colvin, who lives at the apartment that Charlie visited looking for Vince. She considers what to do next.
Charlie follows a lead to a shadow alterationist named Raven, who might have information about Knight Singh. Before he died, Singh gave Raven the notebook Charlie found in Adam’s apartment. Singh told Raven to keep it safe. While the Liber Noctem was at auction, Singh was able to view it and copied out some information on binding Blights.
As Raven fills a mug with blood and leaves it for her collected shadows to feed on, she explains to Charlie how independent shadows work. Raven knew the Hierophant before he was changed—he used to be a thief; now he is being controlled by a Blight. Raven says the trick to controlling shadows that could become Blights is to view them as extensions of yourself and never give them a name or feed them the blood of another person. Finally, a person with no shadow can’t be controlled by another.
Later, Charlie and Posey practice exercises to enhance Charlie’s shadow but without success. Charlie finds an article on Rose, the girl that Edmund Carver was supposedly found dead with, and tabloid rumors about Edmund and Adeline’s incestual relationship. Posey reads tarot cards for Charlie and draws the Magician, the Fool, and the Hierophant.
The midpoint of the novel escalates the tension and the stakes by removing Charlie’s primary support system—Vince. This leaves Charlie alone and forces her to take action: “If she couldn’t be responsible or careful or good or loved, if she was doomed to be a lit match, then Charlie might as well go back to finding stuff to burn” (140). The changed circumstances now force our protagonist to stop reacting to events (what Charlie has been doing for the majority of the story) and start taking initiative. In response, Charlie at first slips back into the comfort of old, toxic habits: targeting Adam with her con artist skills, getting blackout drunk, and being thrown out of a bar. While dysfunctional, these actions signal that Charlie is through accepting whatever life throws her way; after hitting this nadir, she launches into a multi-pronged investigation of the alley murder, Edmund Carver’s real life, the location of the Liber Noctem, and the shadow magic of Blights with the mysterious shadow alterationist Raven.
Charlie’s descent is contrasted with her brief glimpse of how the other half lives. Outside the bar, she encounters a “matte black Rolls-Royce of legend” and its owner’s “silver-tipped cane” (160)—artifacts that demonstrate Lionel Salt’s status as a man who treats himself to expensive versions of even functional things like cars and mobility devices. Salt both threatens and coerces Charlie; his treatment of her highlights his perception of The Insularity of the Wealthy: “For Salt to be comfortable having his gun out reminded Charlie that he believed he could get away with anything” (162). The novel moves into a milieu unfamiliar to Charlie: spas, saunas, expensive dining, and athleisure wear. Coupled with these luxurious trappings is the suggestion of deeply insidious corruption: A tabloid speculates that Salt’s grandson, Edmund, and granddaughter, Adeline, were in an incestuous relationship, highlighting how little regard the wealthy have for the mores that govern the lives of everyone else.
The flashback chapters now deepen the reader’s understanding of Vince’s past, identifying him as both Edmund Carver and Remy, whose shadow Red has become a Blight. We learn meaningful similarities between Vince and Charlie’s childhoods; both are coping with The Influence of the Past, as both were coopted by adults in their lives to participate in criminal activity. Posey’s old concerns that Rand was grooming Charlie are indirectly accurate: While Rand did not have sexual designs on the teenage Charlie, he did train her for a life as a con artist and a thief, using manipulative coercion that relied on the fact that she was distant from her own father. Similarly, Lionel Salt used his grandson’s love for his family and magical facility with Red to enrich himself and force the young man to be an accessory to murder.
The novel borrows from several genres to ground its supernatural elements, using tropes that fulfill reader expectations. For example, several scenes—such as Charlie and Raven’s interaction—rely on elements common to mysteries and noir thrillers. Raven’s dark allure identifies her as a version of the femme fatale—a highly desirable woman who maneuvers the detective into danger while providing clues about the mystery being solved. In contrast, the scene of Posey and Charlie reading tarot cards is more straightforwardly out of the fantasy genre. Here, the cards produce results that cryptically foreshadow the plot, introducing a series of symbolic motifs for readers to recognize after they recur. In this case, while Balthazar has already seemingly identified the Hierophant as the disembodied shadow murderer Charlie saw earlier, the Magician and the Fool are for now harder to name.
By Holly Black
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Daughters & Sons
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
Nature Versus Nurture
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
The Power & Perils of Fame
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection