55 pages • 1 hour read
Rebecca WellsA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide describes the novel’s treatment of substance misuse disorders, mental health conditions, death by suicide, child abuse, and domestic abuse.
In the novel, the bond between Vivi and Sidda represents the tenacity of mother-daughter bonds. It survives complications and misunderstandings, which is a testament to its strength. It is a biological and emotional bond that is connected to memory and shared experiences. The novel opens with a conflict between Sidda and her mother after Sidda’s interview is published in the New York Times; in it, Sidda criticizes Vivi’s parenting, which causes a rift between them. The novel begins with this conflict and charts their journey to eventual reconciliation.
When Vivi and Sidda are angry with one another and not communicating, their unhappiness spills over into every aspect of their lives; this shows the importance of their bond since they are very disturbed when it is broken. Their conflict is really the result of years of unspoken resentment simmering between them. Sidda harbors anger and pain because she remembers Vivi physically abusing her and her siblings, and she also recalls her mother’s multiple absences from the family. When Sidda was a child, her world revolved around her mother—the way Vivi smelled, looked, spoke—and she was deeply traumatized by Vivi’s abandonment. On the other hand, Vivi feels guilty about her parenting mistakes while simultaneously resenting that Sidda can make her feel this way even all these years later. Vivi wonders: “Must I carry my daughter inside me all my life?” (18). When she was younger, she was overwhelmed by the stresses of motherhood; and now, she yearns to be free from guilt for her past mistakes.
Vivi shares the Ya-Yas’ scrapbook with Sidda in an attempt to reestablish their bond by showing Sidda her side of past events. As Sidda reads the scrapbook, she comes across various memories that explain pieces of her mother. She realizes she is a “second generation Ya-Ya” and starts to accept her place as her mother’s daughter since she comes to admire Vivi’s courage, loyalty, and principles (115). At one point, Sidda wonders about “the subliminal knowledge that passes between a mother and a daughter. The preverbal knowledge, the stories told without words, flowing like blood” when a mother carries her daughter inside her body (202). Sidda realizes this deep, physical bond links her to Vivi; she shares so much with Vivi, like her love of drama and stories, as well as shared memories and experiences. Also, as she discovers Vivi’s history with Jack and how that heartbreak affected Vivi’s life subsequently, Sidda realizes that her fear of loving Connor and possibly losing him might stem from her mother’s trauma, which has been passed down to Sidda as a fear of love.
Sidda and Vivi have a link between them that is supernatural at times; their closeness transcends their temporary conflicts and connects them across distances. For instance, each time Sidda uncovers a memory in the scrapbook, her mother, too, thinks about those same memories. Sidda compares their connection to that of elephants, who can communicate with one another across great distances. She realizes that her fear of her mother abandoning her was unwarranted, as Vivi is there to help her when she needs it. Moreover, Vivi knows exactly how to help her. For example, when Sidda hesitates to marry Connor, Vivi sends her the key, which reminds Sidda of how she overcame her fears as a child to embrace a special experience.
When Sidda goes back home for Vivi’s birthday, she is shocked to be warmly embraced by her mother, who harbors no resentment toward her daughter. The women share a moment of bonding and mutual understanding. They touch palms and realize how similar they are. Sidda finds peace through the experience and finds the courage to marry Connor and give herself over to love. Vivi dances at Sidda’s wedding, joyful at being reunited with her daughter, and Sidda joins in.
The novel tells the stories of Sidda’s troubles in the present and how they link back to the past stories and secrets of the Ya-Ya sisterhood. This structure blends past and present, with the novel removing the boundaries between them and revealing them to be directly and intimately connected.
From its opening pages, the novel shows that memories of past events have a bearing on the present. The novel’s prologue sees Sidda remembering a moment from her childhood—she feels abandoned by her mother in that early memory and is rescued from her loneliness by a supernatural vision of the Virgin Mary who smiles down at young Sidda. In the novel, Mary comes to represent The Power of Female Friendships. So, Sidda’s early past is essentially mirrored in her present life as an adult when she once again feels abandoned by her mother in her time of need, but their relationship is repaired by their friends, the Ya-Yas.
The scrapbook—the “Divine Secrets”—is another way that past and present are connected in the novel. Vivi gives Sidda the scrapbook so that she may comb through its memories without Vivi having to relive them herself, and she does this with the hope that Sidda will find clarity in her present by examining her own past and Vivi’s past. Sidda has vivid memories of her childhood and the time she spent with her mother and the other Ya-Yas—she calls this a “Gumbo Ya-Ya” (43), a mixture of all the sights, scents, and sounds from her childhood. As she pores over the scrapbook, she sees snippets of their lives and feels closer to them than ever. Sidda remembers that she is a Petite Ya-Ya, born into a long line of strong women.
Memories are shown to have the power to alter characters’ perspectives—and therefore their choices—in the present. As Sidda’s childhood memories start to come back to her, one of these memories in particular alters her entire perspective. In recalling the day that she almost missed the elephant ride, Sidda feels that same sense of regret and self-castigation that she felt on that day. She recalls, too, the way her mother picked her up out of her frozen state and encouraged her to embrace life. Recalling all of this helps Sidda realize that she need not fear love and that to immerse herself in love and life, she must be willing to risk some pain. This impacts her decision to embrace love and marriage with Connor.
While the past has a clear impact on Sidda’s present, it also impacts Vivi’s attitude toward Sidda. After sending the scrapbook to Sidda, Vivi, too, begins recalling memories—some of which are not fully revealed in the scrapbook and which she instead keeps close to her heart. As Sidda looks at a photograph or scrap of paper at her cabin in Washington, Vivi recalls those associated memories back in Louisiana. While the novel reveals these memories in full, they are not fully revealed to Sidda. Thus, Sidda gains only a partial understanding of the past, but it is enough to get what she needs from the scrapbook. For instance, Sidda never gets the full story behind Jack’s death and what an enormous impact it had on her mother; instead, as she looks at a photograph of Jack and Vivi together in their youth, Sidda “could only study the photo and wonder” (127). She has no idea about “the tectonic shift that took place in [Vivi]” after Jack’s death (127). Even at the age of 70, Vivi admits to Teensy that Jack’s memory still haunts her. As Vivi thinks back on this past trauma, she understands that just as these events affect her present, they also affect her daughter’s. She understands Sidda’s hesitation to commit herself to love as being engendered by Vivi’s own past, and this is why she knows how to fix it. In the end, Sidda finds that it is not the truth that matters, but whether a person can reach out with love.
The sense of sisterhood and communal tribalism that the Ya-Ya women share is what defines them and makes them stand out as a unique group of women. They found one another when they were very young children and have been inseparable ever since. The Ya-Yas are unapologetically themselves when they are together. They share a deep and unspoken understanding of support and unconditional forgiveness. They do not judge or hold grudges against one another. Their love and loyalty enrich their lives as well as the lives of all whom they decide to turn their light of friendship on, like Sidda. She compares the experience of growing up among the Ya-Yas to being part of “a communal tribe, a little primitive matriarchal village” (40).
The Ya-Yas are more than friends; they call each other sisters and establish their closeness through a blood ritual at their initiation ceremony. This ritual is a symbolic and significant moment in the building of the sisterhood; it solidifies them as friends and sisters for life. At the ritual, they give themselves new names, dance naked, share blood, and send candles out into the bayou. They take on titles that match their talents or interests: For instance, Vivi is named “Mistress of Legend” since she is imaginative and likes to invent stories, while Necie’s title is “Mistress of Refreshments” since she loves food and always provides it at their meetings. In this way, the Ya-Yas acknowledge and respect one another, making space for their individual differences.
The depth of the Ya-Yas’ friendship initially seems insular to Sidda; however, she realizes that they make places for all their loved ones among them. Sidda recalls that, as a child, she always felt a certain jealousy toward the Ya-Yas, particularly because they seemed more interested in each other than in their children. Looking at photos of them together as teenagers, Sidda wishes for close friendships like theirs in her own life. She thinks: “I want to lay up like that, to float unstructured, without ambition or anxiety. I want to inhabit my life like a porch” (79). However, as she delves into their pasts, she comes to see that their love for one another didn’t simply exist because they were carefree; it existed despite their problems. When the Ya-Yas sense that Sidda is struggling and needs their help, they happily include her in their world, and she comes to see that she was always one of them.
The Ya-Yas also share their scrapbook with Sidda, which allows her to look into their intimate past and provides her with the insight she needs to overcome her fear of love. Sidda looks at a photo of the Ya-Yas when they were pregnant and remarks to Connor that they didn’t stop drinking and smoking. However, Connor points out something else about the women; he is most impressed by their “sisterhood and the laughter and the not being so damn alone in the world” (313). Humor and companionship are the defining traits of the Ya-Yas, and although Sidda always felt apart from it, they always considered her a member of the group. She realizes that she was always loved, just not in the conventional way. Through the Ya-Yas’ attitudes of loyalty and courage, Sidda finds the strength to accept love into her own life.
Sidda calls off her wedding when it occurs to her that she has never learned how to love and thus would not make a good wife to Connor. She expresses this in a letter to Vivi, who replies: “Do you think any of us know how to love?! Do you think anybody would ever do anything if they waited until they knew how to love?!” (25). At the beginning of the novel, Sidda wants to control every aspect of life, which is why she fears love—specifically, she fears that love might cause her pain. However, by the novel’s conclusion, she comes to realize that she can’t control and dissect her relationships, and that though love might indeed bring pain, it will also bring her joy.
Sidda worries that she didn’t have positive relationship role models as a child. The marriage between her mother and father was not healthy or happy. Additionally, Sidda’s own relationship with her mother is filled with conflicts and misunderstandings. As a child, she adored her mother and remembers her abandoning the family a couple times, which shook young Sidda’s world. This fear of abandonment rears its head in her adulthood, in her relationship with Connor; Sidda doesn’t want to marry him because she fears that she will lose him eventually to death. Sidda questions her own conflict when she wonders, “Is […] the fear of being held in the warmth of familiar love versus the fear of running through the fog, searching for love [greater]? Each holds its own terrors, extracts its own pounds of flesh” (114). While Sidda is aware that loneliness is painful, she knows that love is painful, too, and she cannot determine which is worse. At the novel’s conclusion, she overcomes her fear of loss, deciding that the happiness that love brings is greater than the pain.
Vivi has her own struggles with love and the pain associated with it. She lost her first love, Jack, when she was 16, and she was never the same after that. Sidda carries some of this conflict within herself, too, and Vivi understands this. Vivi went through a period of intense joy when she and Jack first fell in love, and this was followed by one of the darkest periods of her life. When she married Shep, she did love him, but it was not the same degree of affection that she felt for Jack; Vivi could never bring herself to fully open up to Shep. At the same time, Shep was withdrawn, often absent, and often drinking heavily. Vivi’s experience of love as a source of pain also came from her experiences of childrearing; while she loved her four children, she was overwhelmed by caring for them. With time, however, she delights in her relationship with her children and finds peace with Shep. Vivi’s purest and most joyous love came from the Ya-Yas, and it was this unconditional bond that kept her going through all life’s problems.