42 pages • 1 hour read
José RizalA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Father Dámaso appears at the bedside of María-Clara and reveals a sensitive side that surprises onlookers. Lucas appears and informs Father Salví that Ibarra refused to pay a settlement for his brother’s death. When he asks for advice, both priests rebuke him.
To Tiburcio’s surprise, María-Clara recuperates. Doña Victorina and Father Salví engage in a lively debate on science and religion. Salví claims that María-Clara’s condition is attributable to divine intervention, whereas Victorina believes it is due to her husband’s medical expertise (i.e., the use of marshmallow syrup). Aunt Isabella helps María-Clara prepare for confession, which will be conducted by Salví. She reads the ten commandments, with the girl crying at the first five and stopping for the last five. When the confession is over, Salví emerges shaken.
Elías meets with a man named Captain Pablo in a cave some distance away from town. They discuss a planned rebellion that Pablo has been organizing with a group of subversives. Elías tries to talk the man out of it, as he believes he can get Ibarra to sympathize with the plight of the common people. Pablo is skeptical but agrees to wait until Elías meets with the idealist.
This chapter takes place in a building where cockfights are held. Among the crowd are two brothers, Bruno and Társilo, the men whose father was killed by the civil guard at the theater. They bet on cockfights, but when the main event arrives, they are out of money. Lucas reappears and offers to loan them money if they agree to conduct an attack on the barracks. He claims Ibarra is secretly behind the planned attack.
Doña Victorina is out for a walk through town. She admonishes her husband for being polite to the ensign, as he did not compliment her dress. Doña Consolación is at home, and the two talk. Tempers flare, and the women engage in a loud, vicious dispute. When the exchange ends, Victorina is still heated, and she charges Linares (María-Clara’s prospective fiancé) with challenging the ensign to a duel.
Ibarra returns and visits Tiago’s house. He sees Linares with María-Clara and feels aggrieved. Linares is uncomfortable. The exchange between Ibarra and María-Clara is muted by Linares’s presence. Ibarra leaves and heads to the new school, still being constructed. He runs into Elías, who asks to speak at the lake.
Father Salví’s shadowy presence looms throughout the novel. His involvement in the disappearance of young Basilio and Crispin can only be inferred and speculated by others in the community. Salví is almost always present when María-Clara is and often appears agitated. The reader is left to infer that his discomfort stems from lust for María-Clara, who makes it clear that she feels uncomfortable around him. In Chapter 44, as María-Clara recovers from illness, Doctor de Espadaña prescribes a medicinal regimen that includes marshmallow syrup. He clearly does not know what he is doing, as he is only a “doctor” because his wife wants social capital. However, Salví claims the alternative remedy of confession will cure María-Clara. This juxtaposition is significant, as it creates an equivalence between fake medicine and confession as cures for illness. When Salví finally arranges a private meeting with María-Clara, he emerges shaken: “If you had seen his dark brow, covered in sweat, you would have said it was he who had confessed, and did not deserve absolution” (294). As is often the case, the narrator’s comments are ambiguous with hints of incrimination. When compiling evidence regarding Salví’s personality, one can deduce that he likely made a sexual advance toward María-Clara—one that was shut down.
When the narrative shifts back to Elías, he is in a cave outside of town, meeting with a man named Pablo. The scene is cast in shadows, reflecting the dark, secretive nature of the men’s discussion. Pablo believes a violent uprising is the only way to initiate reforms for the Indigenous population. While understanding of Pablo’s resolve, Elías convinces him to hold off on the uprising. He acknowledges the need for reform and highlights Ibarra’s caring, progressive outlook. He believes Ibarra’s status as a well-respected man will help them enact change. Ultimately, Elías convinces Pablo to stay the uprising under the condition that he will join his group should his appeal to Ibarra fail. This exchange illustrates that even the most disenchanted, such as Elías and Pablo, are willing to place hope in nonviolent solutions to societal ills.