39 pages • 1 hour read
Johnnie ChristmasA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
At school during the week before the state championship, Bree runs into the hall monitor, who admits that, like Bree, she didn’t know how to swim. She tells Bree that she started taking lessons because of her. She hopes that Bree will go back to the swim team.
Later, Bree finishes the puzzle she’s been working on since she moved to Florida. Her dad makes all her favorites for dinner. He tells Bree that he doesn’t know how to swim. He almost drowned when he was younger, and he’s afraid to be around pools, which is why he’s avoided going to her meets. He adds that he’s proud of her. He thinks she should rejoin the team, but if nothing else, she should stay in touch with the team. Just then, Bree has a realization: She grabs the photo Etta gave her and says that Etta clearly misses her friends. They need to go to the bank.
There, they find Yvette, and Bree explains to her that Etta needs her team. Then, they go to the dentist’s office, where they meet Jamie. Yvette wonders if Etta will really want to see their fourth teammate.
The panels shift to a memory, with letters spelling out “What Went Down” across the top (202). Yvette and Jamie explain that, when they were kids, legal segregation ended, but many public pools became private, barring Black people from becoming members. Many of the public pools were in white communities, so as Black families moved into those neighborhoods, white families left. There was some overlap in which the public schools were a mix of white and Black students.
Etta’s swim team excelled, and the four girls were very close. One day, the fourth member of the team, Mari, invited the rest of the girls to the pool in a different neighborhood. However, the security guard let Mari in because she was white, but the other girls were Black. When he threatened to call the police on Etta, Yvette, and Jamie, Mari left them to go hang out with her other friends. The three of them, still in their bathing suits, had to take the bus home. The next morning, at the state championship, Mari didn’t show up.
By then, Bree has figured out who Mari is, and they go to the diner, where they find her working. Bree convinces her to come with them, even though she adds that she can’t promise Etta will forgive her. However, she knows Etta needs to get her team back together.
The scene shifts to Etta’s apartment, where Yvette and Jamie greet her. When Mari appears, Etta rebukes her at first, but then Mari apologizes. She says that they’re still a team and that she wants to help. They declare that they’re “swim sisters” again (211).
The next day at school, Bree goes over to Clara and offers to help her study for the math part of her Holyoke Prep exam. Bree apologizes, and Clara reassures her that they’ll still be friends, even if Clara goes to Holyoke. Clara gives her friendship bracelet back.
Clara, Phillipa, Keisha, and Bree all apologize to one another, and Bree asks to come back to the team. They also declare that they are “swim sisters” (215).
At practice that afternoon, Etta and the coach are joined by Yvette, Jamie, and Mari. They go over endurance, diving, and speed. When Phillipa doubts herself, Jamie reminds her that she helps to hold the team together with her humor. She also suggests that Phillipa switch to breaststroke for the medley.
On the day of the championship, Bree’s father apologizes because he has his final presentation for his program. Bree says that she understands, and then they meet Etta, who is very excited. Phillipa is in good spirits, wearing an anchor as a temporary tattoo.
The races start, and it all comes down to the relay medley. Keisha will swim backstroke, Phillipa breaststroke, Clara butterfly, and Bree freestyle. Etta reminds them to have a good time. Just as Bree is about to dive off for her leg, she sees her dad in the audience. She dives off, and despite starting off behind Tinsley from Holyoke, Bree wins the state championship. The team celebrates, and Etta and her team celebrate, with both yelling, “Swim sisters!” (237).
The Holyoke Prep coach begins to yell at her students, but they stand up to her, reminding her that winning isn’t everything. They walk away from her. Then, Etta convinces the coach to invite the Holyoke students to join them for ice cream. Tinsley even compliments Bree.
At the diner, Clara announces that she passed the math exam. Bree says that she’ll miss her, but Clara reminds her that they live in the same building.
Sometime later, Bree teaches her father how to float in the pool.
It is important that Bree isn’t present when Etta and Mari reconcile. Her absence shows how difficult of a moment this is, and Bree also has to go through the same process with her friends. Each set of swim sisters cares deeply for one another, and they have their own identities. However, the two stories are connected, as Bree reminds Etta what it means to have swim sisters and Etta teaches Bree the value of friendship in and out of the pool. The reconciliation with their respective friends also brings the theme of Friendship as More Important Than Competition to a resolution. While everyone at Enith Brigitha wants to win the state championship, they are content with being able to have experienced the swim season together, knowing now that their friendship is the most important takeaway from working together.
Additionally, Bree feels deeply empowered, having learned from the hall monitor that she isn’t the only one who had never learned how to swim. Bree feels herself taking part in a larger lineage of swimming, which she learned about from Etta and through the fact that they both swam for a school named for a Black Olympic swimmer. This feeling of empowerment makes her tell her swim sisters, “My dad says one butterfly can change the weather. I say four butterflies can change the world” (215). She feels deeply grateful to have joined the team and is much more confident in herself and in her teammates. Her team also has a larger effect on the teams around them, as the Holyoke Prep students stand up to their coach, rebuking her criticisms by saying, “We lost States, but it doesn’t make us losers” (240).
Bree also feels confident in her life. She has done everything that she was nervous to do at the beginning of the novel, having joined a sports team, learned how to swim, and made new friends. When she solves the puzzle that her father gave her at the outset of the novel, she also solves the puzzle of Etta and her friends, linking the two inextricably. She worked hard, and she knows then how to make Etta’s life better, wanting her to have the relationship she wants with her swim sisters.
Additionally, The Lasting Effects of Segregation and Discrimination is brought to a close in this novel by the fact that the pool will continue to exist at Enith Brigitha, succeeding in making sure that the school board does not “take away pool access, like when I was a girl” (141). Their success at the state championship ensures its future. Furthermore, Bree also gets to pass down the knowledge of swimming, like many before her, though she does it by helping her father learn how to swim, showing how she has now become the teacher, telling him, “You’re learning fast. Piece by piece, it’s all…coming together” (244-45).