The Demon of Unrest: A Saga of Hubris, Heartbreak, and Heroism at the Dawn of the Civil War

1. General Impressions

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

• Which literary genres does Larson draw from to depict the tumultuous period leading up to the Civil War? How do these genre conventions shape the readers’ experience of the text?
• How does The Demon of Unrest differ from a conventional history textbook? What do the text’s personal narratives add to the readers’ understanding of historical events?
• Compare and contrast The Demon of Unrest to And There Was Light (2023) or another nonfiction work about the Civil War. How do these texts differ in their approach to creating a historical narrative? 

2. Personal Reflection and Connection

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences and perspectives..

• What political, cultural, and socioeconomic issues from 1860 still exist today? Which of those issues have been resolved or significantly improved?
• What lessons from the Civil War can today’s leaders use to improve American society?
• How is the concept of honor portrayed in the book, and how does that concept differ in North and South? Do you agree or disagree with the actions in The Demon of Unrest taken in the name of honor? Is there a better moral standard that could be used to measure an individual’s values and responsibilities?
• Which character or characters do you relate to most in the text and why? How might their circumstances have been different if they were alive today?

3. Societal and Cultural Context

Examine the book’s relevance to broader societal issues, cultural trends, and ethical dilemmas.

• How does The Demon of Unrest portray Black experiences in the North and South in the time leading up to the Civil War? Which characters represent this perspective, and how do their lives change during and after the war?
• Discussion of the role of leadership during times of national crisis, as seen in the actions of figures like Lincoln and Buchanan. How does the book highlight the challenges and responsibilities of leadership, and what lessons can be learned from their decisions?
• How did the controversy surrounding vote counts during Lincoln’s presidential election parallel issues around the electoral process and vote counting in present-day politics? Have those issues been resolved? If not, how might they affect presidential elections in the future?

4. Literary Analysis 

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and use of narrative techniques.

• Analysis of Larson’s narrative structure, particularly his use of personal stories alongside major historical events. How does this approach affect readers’ understanding of the complexities of the period?
• How does Larson explore the concept of chivalry in the South’s upper class society? How is this concept developed through the thoughts and actions of key figures, such as James and Mary Chestnut?
• Examine the tensions that existed between the major political parties and their leaders before the start of the Civil War. How do leaders like Lincoln and Buchanan navigate these tensions to avoid a full-scale civil war? Why weren’t their efforts successful, and what does this reveal about the nature of leadership during crises?
• What literary devices does Larson use to heighten emotional engagement with the characters, create atmosphere, and dramatize historic events? How does he create suspense when recounting events that have already taken place? Use examples from the text in your response.

5. Creative Engagement

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book’s content and themes.

• Does The Demon of Unrest give a balanced portrayal of individuals who supported the Confederacy versus those that supported the Union? What allows the reader to connect with these characters, even if they hold vastly different moral and political values?
• What key cultural, personal, or political perspectives are left out of Larson’s text? How would you craft a narrative to highlight erased or forgotten perspectives of the Civil War era?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources.