84 pages • 2 hours read
Howard PyleA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
The narrator briefly introduces the story of Gawaine, or the Knight of the Silver Tongue, saying it is about his faithfulness and good fortune.
While traveling far from Camelot, King Arthur, Queen Guinevere, and their court set up pavilions near the forest to shade them from the midday heat. During their feast, a white deer and a white dog, both with gold collars, run around their table, and then back into the forest. A knight and lady emerge from the forest where the animals ran. Another knight attacks the first knight, knocking him unconscious, and captures the lady, riding back into the forest with her. The unconscious knight’s squires get him on his horse and lead him into the forest as well. Arthur asks if one of his knights will discover what happened to the lady captured by the knight, and Gawaine volunteers, with his younger brother Gaheris as his squire.
Gawaine and Gaheris ride for a while, asking forest folk about the deer, hound, lady, and knight. They arrive at a meadow where two knights are fighting, and they ask about the nature of their dispute. The knights initially will not share their conflict, but when Gawaine asks about the animals and the lady carried off by a knight, they tell him their story. The two knights are brothers who witnessed similar events and argued over whether the deer or hound should win. Then, they argued over who would rescue the lady, and their arguments turned into the physical fight that Gawaine and Gaheris interrupted. After Gawaine condemns them for wounding each other, they introduce themselves—Sir Sorloise and Sir Brian. Gawaine introduces himself and asks the knights to report back to Arthur and his court. They agree to do so and ride off.
Gawaine and Gaheris see a knight next to a river and ask him about the deer, hound, lady, and knight. The knight says he is also in pursuit of them, and Gawaine challenges him over who should continue the adventure. They joust, the knight’s spear breaks, Gawaine’s does not, and the knight is unhorsed. Gawaine checks on him, takes off his helmet, and learns his name is Sir Alardin of the Isles. Gawaine sends Alardin to Arthur and his court.
At sunset, Gawaine and Gaheris reach a plain that holds a castle. They find that the white hound is dead, and the white deer is grazing nearby. The deer runs towards the castle, and Gawaine and Gaheris chase it. In the courtyard of the castle, Gawaine kills the deer and immediately regrets it. The lord and lady of the castle come out, and the lord challenges Gawaine to a fight over his killing of the deer. The lord, Sir Ablamor of the Marise, injures Gawaine, and Gawaine nearly kills Ablamor, but the lady jumps in front of him and Gawaine hits her with the flat of his sword. Ablamor thinks she is dead, and threatens to kill Gawaine, but when she regains consciousness, Ablamor cries with joy.
Gawaine and Gaheris stay at the castle that night, and Ablamor tells them the story of the white deer and hound. He and his brother married two sisters, and these ladies encountered a beautiful damsel in the forest who gave them the white animals with gold collars and leashes. The hound tried to kill the deer, and this caused the households to be in dispute. Ablamor reveals that he is the knight they saw hit his brother and take his wife earlier that day. Gawaine believes the damsel who gave the ladies the animals is Vivien. He convinces Ablamor to release his lady’s sister and make peace with his brother.
When Gawaine returns to Arthur’s court, Guinevere is unhappy that he did not show mercy, and struck a lady. Gawaine breaks his sword and pledges to prove his chivalry to the queen.
Later, Arthur resides at Tintagalon while Guinevere and their courts wait at Carleon. One spring day, Arthur asks his squire Boisenard to go with him on an adventure. They ride into the forest and get lost. After night falls, Boisenard climbs a tree and sees a light. They ride towards it and find a castle. Arthur hides his identity (he is wearing unmarked armor), and the castle porter suggests they sleep outside, but Arthur insists on entering.
Inside, attendants help them clean up and they head into the hall. A knight wearing all black offers seats near him at the head of the table during the feast. After they eat, the knight suggests that they each try to withstand a blow to the head by the other. Arthur hesitates, and Boisenard tries to talk him out of it, but Arthur is determined. The knight offers his bare neck to Arthur, and Arthur beheads him with Excalibur. The body of the knight picks up his head and places it back on his neck. Arthur bares his own neck, and the knight touches his sword to it and swings his sword in the air but does not decapitate Arthur. The knight agrees to spare Arthur’s life if he vows to return in a year and a day. Arthur swears on Excalibur, and the knight offers also to spare Arthur’s life when he returns if he can solve a riddle: what does a woman desire most? In the morning, Arthur leaves the castle.
During the following year, Arthur sets his affairs in order and seeks the answer to the riddle. However, many women offer different responses to the question of what they desire most. Shortly before the year ends, Arthur has Boisenard arm him in the unmarked armor, tells Boisenard what to do if he does not return in a month, and sets off from the castle. He continues to ask women what they desire as he travels towards his destination.
The day before he is due back at the castle, Arthur rides in the forest and discovers a hidden hut. Inside is an ugly old woman who recognizes him. She offers an answer to the riddle if Arthur will marry her to one of his knights. He agrees, and she tells him a woman desires her will above all else. She also tells him the knight carries his life-force in the locket he wears on a necklace, and destroying the locket is the only way to kill him. Arthur thanks her, stays with her that night, and heads to the castle in the morning.
Arthur enters the castle and tells the knight his answer to the riddle: that a woman desires to have her will. The knight is unsure of what to do, and Arthur asks for the knight’s necklace in exchange for the one Arthur wears. When the knight hesitates, Arthur grabs the necklace and breaks the clear ball inside the locket, killing the knight. He then storms out of the castle and goes to the old woman’s hut.
Arthur takes the old woman to Carleon, where everyone is enjoying the May day outside. He tells Guinevere and the court the story of how the old woman saved his life. She chooses Gawaine for her husband, as per her arrangement with Arthur, and Gawaine agrees to marry her. After their wedding, they go to Gawaine’s house, and he hides in his chambers for a while, ashamed. Then he goes to his wife’s room, and she tells him that she is under a curse: for half the day she appears ugly and old, but for the other half of the day, she is beautiful. When they disagree about which part of the day she should be beautiful, Gawaine allows her to win the argument, consenting to her decision.
This, she reveals, is the final test, and she will remain beautiful all the time. Gawaine is overjoyed. She reveals that she is one of the Ladies of the Lake but became mortal (rather than fay) to be with Gawaine. He reveals her beauty to the rest of the house, and they celebrate. The next day, he takes her to see the king and queen, revealing her beauty to the court, and everyone thinks Gawaine is lucky to have her.
The narrator ends the chapter with a lesson for the reader about accepting tasks that seem ugly, like Gawaine’s old damsel, in order to be dutiful and worthy.
The narrator includes a brief conclusion that previews his other books that contain the stories of knights, such as Lancelot and Galahad. The end is a blessing that the reader will be as happy as the knights in his stories.
Part 3, the story of Gawaine, includes elements from the traditional poetic narrative Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, written in the 14th century. However, instead of Gawaine facing a knight who can withstand beheading, it is Arthur who faces the magical knight. In Pyle’s version, the knight is “clad altogether in black” except for a “chain of gold, with a locket of gold” (364), repeating the imagery of the mysterious, supernatural knight in black. The beheading game is a common plot device of chivalric romances, intended to determine the bravery and honor of the knights who participate, i.e. they must be as willing to accept death honorably as they are to deal death to their enemies. Rather than focusing further on Arthur’s well-established honor, however, Pyle has Arthur outsmart his opponent by destroying the “ball of crystal” (374) that holds his life essence. Instead, Pyle creates a more modern test for Arthur: to discover what women want.
In order to solve the knight’s riddle—“What is it that a woman desires most of all in the world?” (368)—Arthur promises to marry a woman, who appears to be old and ugly, to one of his knights. This is where Gawaine enters the story, as the husband chosen by the old woman who saves Arthur’s life. The twist is that the woman is not truly old or ugly. When Arthur first sees her, she is under a spell that transforms her, and is given a blazon that describes her beauty. Blazons are literary devices that usually list beautiful features, but the narrator lists the woman’s features as “covered all over with wrinkles” and “she had but one tooth in her mouth” (370). This can be contrasted with the blazon that describes the woman’s beauty when she is freed by the spell by marrying Gawaine; she is in “the very flower of her youth” (378) her mouth is full of teeth that are “like pearls” (378-379), and she has hair that is “long and glossy and very black” (378). Her beautiful black hair is like Nymue’s hair because she is “one of the Ladies of the Lake” (380)—fay women tend to have black hair.
While under the spell that makes her appear old and ugly, the woman reveals what women want to Arthur: “That which a woman most desires is to have her will” (371). However, Gawaine must demonstrate this lesson as part of a final test before keeping his bride in her beautiful state forever. He married the woman in order to redeem himself for hitting Guinevere’s dog with his hand and hitting a lady with the flat of his sword. When Gawaine says, “thou shalt have thy will in this and in all other things” (380) to his wife, he is treated as overcoming his disrespect for women. Like traditional fairy tales, the narrator closes the story by explicitly stating its moral, as Pyle once again combines storytelling traditions from various centuries.
By Howard Pyle
Action & Adventure
View Collection
Action & Adventure Reads (Middle Grade)
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Books that Teach Empathy
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Medieval Literature / Middle Ages
View Collection
Mythology
View Collection
Order & Chaos
View Collection
Power
View Collection