50 pages • 1 hour read
Ana HuangA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Jules finishes her bar exam despite her injuries. Josh appears as she leaves the exam room, treating her with more warmth than at the ER. She tries not to notice the regret in his eyes, “refused to get [her] hopes up only for him to crush them again” (438). Josh tells Jules that he dealt with Max, apologizes for hurting her, and professes his love. Jules can’t forgive him for weaponizing her insecurities, but he refuses to let her go. She asks for time and space to think, and he accepts her request.
Jules stresses over Josh, distracting herself with work. He visits her at LHAC despite promising her space. She is frustrated with and confused by her inability to forgive him. Asher Donovan, the famous soccer player from Bridget’s wedding, calls Jules and invites her out for drinks. She agrees under the heat of Josh’s gaze. At the bar, she is too distracted by thoughts of Josh to converse with Asher. Asher mentions he never wanted to become famous, that “for the longest time, [he] held [himself] back because [he] was afraid [he] didn’t deserve it” (452). Jules realizes she’s holding back from love because she believes she doesn’t deserve it. Josh appears at the bar, and Asher urges Jules to go to him. Josh promises his feelings for Jules are real and forever, and they profess their mutual love.
Josh brings Jules to his house, and for the first time, they have intimate sex; afterward, they cuddle. Josh assures Jules that he publicly sold his painting so Max’s associates won’t target him. They then discuss revealing their relationship to Ava.
Josh and Jules anxiously reveal their relationship to Ava and Alex. Ava thinks they’re joking, but then voices shock. She pulls Josh away for a private conversation, and he admits he would “take a thousand fights with Jules over a thousand easy days with anyone else. Because [he] didn’t want easy. [He] wanted her” (471).
Ava pulls Jules away for a private conversation, leaving Josh and Alex alone. Alex tells Josh that he plans to propose to Ava, and wants his approval. He then asks Josh to be his best man. Josh jokingly plans a bachelor party.
Jules is questioned by Ava, Stella, and Bridget at a local bar. Their joy for Jules’s new relationship makes her feel as though a “huge weight had lifted off [her] shoulders” (481). The women then question Stella, who is still single. During their conversation, a TV reveals news of Max’s death, rumored to be at the hands of a crime ring. Jules shifts her attention back to her friends, admiring how “[they] weren’t eighteen anymore, but [they] were still [them]” (484).
Josh surprises Jules with a trip to see Legally Blonde: The Musical in New York. While in the city, he shows her where his painting ended up—in the private residence of Dante Russo, Christian Harper’s wealthy friend.
Josh arrives at LHAC to find Jules showing the other staff photos of Alex’s proposal to Ava over the weekend. The couple then discuss their own plans for marriage and agree it’s far in the future.
One month later, Jules passes the bar exam and begins work at Silver & Klein; Josh prepares to enter his final year of residency. After paying his medical school loans, he has “enough money from selling the painting to be financially comfortable for decades” (498). To celebrate, he surprises Jules with a trip to New Zealand in four months. They move in together, and four months later, they bungee jump in New Zealand.
The previous section ended in a third-act breakup, a common plot device in romance novels to add tension. These novels typically end in a Happily Ever After (HEA), where a love interest makes a grand gesture to profess their love and mend their relationship. Most third-act breakups occur because of miscommunication, but Ana Huang subverts the plot device by having Josh commit a questionable act against Jules in retaliation. The dubious consent in Chapter 46 has lasting ramifications that end with Jules eventually forgiving Josh in Chapter 53. Instead of one partner seeking forgiveness from the other, both Jules and Josh must seek forgiveness from each other; it is important to note that while Jules did betray Josh’s trust by robbing him, his retaliation and inability to give her space as requested are not necessarily healthy or justified reactions. In the context of the novel, the couple’s exchange of forgiveness is framed as a healthy give-and-take.
When Josh forgives Jules for her transgression, she does not immediately forgive him. Forgiveness only becomes possible once she locates the root of her fear and insecurities. It is through a conversation with Asher that she realizes she doesn’t believe she deserves love. When Asher reveals he reached his full potential by getting out of his own way, Jules does the same. Though she’s come a long way since her life in Ohio, “some things were so ingrained from childhood that they became a part of [her] without [her] even knowing” (455). Her mother never wanted her, Alastair insisted she have sex with him, and Max never loved her for who she is—making Josh’s relative care touching, yet terrifying for her. Jules’s acceptance of herself and willingness to reenter a relationship—this time, with full transparency—signify the completion of her arc. Her lack of reaction upon hearing of Max’s death also signifies her success in finding Freedom in Closure.
Josh’s arc is also completed with self-reflection. He takes responsibility for his retaliation against Jules as per advice from Alex. The men’s friendship mirrors the emotional side of Josh’s relationship with Jules. Just as Jules convinced Josh to reconcile with Alex, Alex does the same for Josh’s relationship with Jules. Josh’s friendship with Alex shows the importance of connection in times of distress. Without it, Josh might have abused his coping mechanism—Adrenaline Providing Distraction.
Josh and Jules’s trip to New Zealand shows that the couple has formed healthier boundaries around adrenaline. They bungee jump together, and Josh feels alive, but “it wasn’t just the bungee jump. It was the fact [he] was experiencing it with Jules. No one and nothing could make [him] feel as alive as she did” (502). By acknowledging that “New Zealand was a fantasy; D.C. was reality” (504), he embraces his new, more stable life with her.
By Ana Huang
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Asian American & Pacific Islander...
View Collection
Beauty
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Hate & Anger
View Collection
Health & Medicine
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection